My Shopping Basket

Product detail

Home » Dutch Haven Bakery » Pies

Dutch Haven Famous Shoo-fly Pie
1 of 3 (Enlarge)
Dutch Haven Famous Shoo-fly Pie

Dutch Haven Famous Shoo-Fly Pie

Since 1946, Dutch Haven has been famous for America's best Shoo-Fly Pie and today this wet bottom pie is still produced from the original recipe!

Of the thousands of our delicious pies that are sold each year, many are shipped throughout the country. People love to send our pies as yummy thank yous and remembrances - and they are great for family get-togethers. (Hint - receiving a Dutch Haven shoo-fly pie in the mail is a great birthday surprise!) Our gooey, old-fashioned Shoo-Fly pies are a delicious taste of the Pennsylvania Dutch Country!

Named "America's Best Shoo-Fly Pie," Dutch Haven shoo-fly pie is still recognized as the best of the best. Baked in our own bakery using the time-tested recipe, our Shoo-Fly Pie is deservingly famous. People who don't even know they like shoo-fly pie fall in love with our delectable, yummy shoo-fly pie every day! Serve warmed, topped with a dollop (or more!) of whipped cream or a side of ice cream. Delicious!!

Our award-winning recipe consists of the following choice ingredients:  winter wheat pastry flour, vegetable shortening, brown sugar, water, sugar, salt, baking soda, cinnamon, refiners syrup (molasses), and corn syrup.  Dutch Haven Shoo-fly Pies will keep for two (2) weeks at room temperature; one (1) month refrigerated; can be frozen.  Net weight:  2 lbs, 9 oz.  

Dutch Haven is "The Place that Made Shoo-Fly Pie Famous!"  Order yours today and you'll understand why!  (We also offer other pies including Chocolate Shoo-fly, Pecan, and Chocolate Pecan Pie ... maybe even some delicious Whoopie Pies!  Orders requesting pies other than regular Shoo-Fly pies must be called in directly to the store.)

For additional pie selections, wholesale prices or any other questions, please call our store at

First Shoo-Fly Pie: $37.99

Additional Pies shipped to same address: $23.00

(includes shipping & handling)

Pies will arrive within 7 business days or less.  For express delivery, please contact store. 

Dutch Haven is not responsible for lost, misdirected, or returned packages due to incomplete or incorrect addresses.  Please be sure to include any applicable apartment or suite numbers when ordering.


Price: $37.99

 If this is a gift, you may include a message with your order that will be included with the Shoofly Pie (up to 100 characters).
 If you have any additional shipping instructions or information you would like us to have, please make note here.